Have you ever felt like a backup plan in your dating life, or perhaps unknowingly kept someone on the back burner yourself? As explored in the insightful discussion above with dating coach Treva Brandon Scharf, understanding modern dating phenomena like cushioning is crucial, especially when navigating the landscape of online dating over 50. It’s a term that may sound innocuous, but its implications can deeply affect emotional well-being and relationship integrity.
What is Cushioning in Online Dating?
In the evolving lexicon of online dating, terms like “ghosting” and “benching” have become common parlance. Cushioning is another behavior that warrants careful attention, particularly for singles re-entering the dating world later in life. Simply put, cushioning refers to the act of maintaining communication and flirtation with multiple potential romantic interests, not merely as a single person keeping options open, but while already involved in what appears to be a committed or exclusive relationship.
Initially, during the early stages of dating, it’s natural and often advisable to explore connections with several individuals. This is distinct from cushioning. When you are single and actively seeking a partner, having “people in rotation” or “on the bench” (as Treva explains) means you’re not putting all your eggs in one basket before a clear commitment is established. You might be going on dates with various people, assessing compatibility, and not rushing into exclusivity. This approach can be a positive strategy, protecting you from emotional over-investment and ensuring you make a well-considered choice.
However, the ethical line is crossed with cushioning when one party is in a seemingly exclusive relationship, yet continues to nurture these “cushions” on the side. These individuals typically remain unaware that they are merely an emotional safety net. They are not just on the bench; they are a contingency plan, an alternative to “soften the blow” should the primary relationship falter. This covert behavior speaks volumes about the cushioner’s motives and often stems from deeper insecurities or a profound fear of being alone.
The Psychological Underpinnings of Cushioning
Why do people engage in cushioning? The reasons are multifaceted, often revealing more about the individual cushioner than the dynamics of the primary relationship itself. Treva Brandon Scharf directly addresses this, stating it often stems from either selfishness or deep-seated insecurity. Let’s delve into these core psychological drivers:
-
Insecurity and the Need for Validation
For many, cushioning is a constant quest for external validation. The digital age, with its instant gratification and endless swiping, makes this pursuit alarmingly easy. Social media platforms and dating apps offer a readily available stream of attention, “likes,” and messages that can temporarily fill an internal void. If a person feels inadequate or lacks self-worth, maintaining multiple potential partners can provide a continuous ego boost, affirming their attractiveness or desirability. This isn’t about genuine connection; it’s about sustaining a fragile sense of self.
-
Fear of Abandonment or Loneliness
The prospect of a relationship ending can be terrifying, especially for those who have experienced past heartbreaks or are dating over 50 after a long-term marriage or partnership. Cushioning acts as a preventative measure against this emotional pain. By having backup options, the cushioner believes they can mitigate the impact of a breakup, ensuring they won’t be left “alone.” This strategy, however, prevents them from fully investing in their current relationship and ultimately sabotages the potential for true intimacy.
-
Commitment Phobia and a “Player” Mentality
Some individuals are genuinely averse to full commitment. They enjoy the attention and benefits of a relationship but balk at the idea of singular devotion. For these “players,” cushioning is a way to keep their options perpetually open, ensuring they never feel trapped or tied down. This behavior, whether conscious or subconscious, prioritizes personal freedom (or fear of commitment) over the emotional needs and expectations of their primary partner.
-
Lack of Self-Awareness and Emotional Maturity
Perhaps the most challenging aspect of cushioning is that some individuals may not even recognize the harm they are causing. A lack of self-awareness can lead them to believe they are simply being “friendly” or “keeping options open,” even when their behavior clearly crosses into unethical territory within an exclusive context. Emotional maturity involves understanding the impact of one’s actions on others and choosing honesty and integrity, even when uncomfortable.
The Impact of the Online Dating Environment
The prevalence of cushioning has undoubtedly been exacerbated by the online dating landscape. Where once one might have only a few casual acquaintances to consider, dating apps present a seemingly infinite supply of potential matches. This “paradox of choice” can make it harder for individuals to commit, constantly wondering if there’s someone “better” just a swipe away. The ease of communication – texting, messaging, social media interactions – further facilitates cushioning, allowing discreet conversations to unfold with minimal effort. This digital buffer often makes it easier to dehumanize potential partners, reducing them to profiles and conversations rather than fully-fledged individuals with feelings and expectations.
Navigating the Ethical Minefield: When is Cushioning Acceptable?
As discussed in the video, the line between acceptable “keeping your options open” and unethical cushioning hinges on one critical factor: honesty and mutual understanding of relationship status. Here’s a breakdown:
-
Acceptable: Early Stages of Dating (No Exclusivity)
When you are genuinely single and not in an exclusive relationship, dating multiple people is not only acceptable but often recommended. This allows you to explore compatibility, understand your preferences, and avoid putting all your emotional energy into one person prematurely. During this phase, if you decide one person stands out, you naturally “clear the bench” and focus your attention there. The key here is transparency: neither party has agreed to exclusivity, so there are no unspoken expectations being violated.
-
Unacceptable: During an Exclusive or Committed Relationship
Once you and a partner have mutually agreed to be exclusive, or if you are in a committed relationship, cushioning becomes an ethical breach. At this point, you owe your partner your full attention, loyalty, and honesty. Maintaining flirtatious contact with others, especially without your partner’s knowledge, is a form of emotional infidelity. It undermines trust, creates a power imbalance, and can be deeply hurtful if discovered. This is where cushioning aligns with behaviors like emotional cheating, indicating a failure to fully invest in the chosen relationship.
Taking Action: For the Cushioner and the Cushionee
Whether you find yourself engaging in cushioning or suspect you are on the receiving end, both parties have a responsibility to address the situation with honesty and integrity.
If You Are the Cushioner: Self-Reflection is Key
If you recognize elements of cushioning in your own dating behavior, it’s a powerful opportunity for introspection. Ask yourself:
- **What am I truly seeking?** Is it a committed partnership, or just validation?
- **Why do I need these ‘cushions’?** What fear or insecurity are they addressing?
- **Am I being fair and honest with my primary partner?** Are my actions aligned with the expectations of our relationship?
- **What is missing within myself that I’m trying to fill externally?** This is often the hardest question, but the most crucial.
As Treva passionately emphasizes, relying on others to fill an “empty hole in your soul” is a fruitless endeavor. True fulfillment and security must come from within. Consider seeking personal growth through therapy or coaching to address underlying insecurities or commitment issues. Choosing honesty, even when difficult, is always the more ethical and ultimately healthier path.
If You Are the Cushionee: Recognize the Signs and Set Boundaries
It can be incredibly painful to realize you might be someone’s backup plan. However, as Treva notes, “people are not stupid; they pick up on that.” Trust your instincts if something feels off. Signs might include:
- Your partner being overly secretive about their phone or online activity.
- Evasive answers when you ask about their relationships with others.
- Feeling like you’re not a priority, despite their declarations of commitment.
- A general sense of emotional distance or superficiality in the relationship.
If you suspect you’re a cushionee, courageous communication is essential. Confronting the issue directly, calmly, and assertively can bring clarity. State your needs and expectations clearly. For instance, you might say, “I want a committed and exclusive relationship where I feel like a priority. If that’s not what you’re ready for, then this isn’t the right fit for me.” This approach, though challenging, respects your self-worth and allows you to move forward, whether within the relationship (if issues are resolved) or by seeking a more fulfilling connection elsewhere. As Treva encourages, just say it. Just state your truth.
The Golden Rule: Be a Kind Human
Ultimately, dating, especially online dating over 50, should be grounded in respect and kindness. Regardless of relationship status or dating trends, we are all interacting with human beings who deserve to be treated with dignity. The anonymity of a screen does not excuse poor behavior. Whether you’re ending a first date that didn’t click or navigating the complexities of an exclusive relationship, choose honesty, communicate clearly, and strive to leave others feeling respected, not used. This ethical approach not only fosters better connections but also reflects positively on your own character and emotional intelligence in the dating world.
Decoding Cushioning and Digital Dating Over 50: Your Q&A
What is ‘cushioning’ in online dating?
Cushioning is when someone maintains communication and flirts with multiple potential romantic interests while they are already in an exclusive or committed relationship.
Is it always bad to talk to multiple people when dating?
No, it is acceptable to date multiple people in the early stages when you are genuinely single and not yet in an exclusive relationship. Cushioning becomes an issue when it happens after a commitment has been made.
Why do people engage in cushioning behavior?
People often engage in cushioning due to insecurities, a fear of being alone, or a reluctance to fully commit. It can serve as a way to seek validation or have a backup option.
What are some signs that I might be a ‘cushionee’?
Signs you might be a cushionee include your partner being overly secretive about their online activity, giving evasive answers about other relationships, or a general feeling that you are not their priority despite their declarations.